[oi-dev] OpenIndiana Code of Conduct

[Bart Coddens]

Please Nikola,

Take your bike out and go for a ride in the countryside.
This everlasting tirade/rant does not help the community or yourself.
Just my 2c,

Bart

2016-07-25 10:05 GMT+02:00 Nikola M <minikola at gmail.com>:

> On 07/24/16 05:40 PM, Aurélien Larcher wrote:
> > It is only democratic to pull the plug out of that page, showing that
> > unfunished undemocratic documents like that should not have democratic
> > support at all, promoting autoritarian rula and forcing it.
> >
> > Other then that, democratic way could be having links on that page
> > pointing to Wiki so people can contribute there, but I choosed to have
> > both of them presented concurrently, old useless one and newer rewriting
> > of it.
> > If work occurs on the Wiki then it is natural to point to it.
>
> But it is not natural to have stale and bad  old version of it on site
> for no reason.
>
> Plus xenol yesterday changed on-Wiki article name, that is not done on
> existing articles.
> Also xenol received reccomendations on how to edit Wiki in a right way.
>
> Only problem with it is that those "not to be tolerated" parts of
> proposal are idiotic
> and can't be glued into document, for not being precise and pushing
> community into one-man slavery.
>
> >
> >>
> >> So xenol does not have right to PUT it on the site unilaterally.
> >>
> >> And I have ALL right to change and rephrase and contribute improved
> >> version as I did on wiki.
> > You have the right to setup a workspace but modifying website content is
> subject to review.
>
> Great, xenol modified website without public review. Deal with it first.
>
> >
> >> Plus I have rights on site to change documents, so why not I use them to
> >> change?
> > Because the rule on the website is: do not modify existing content
> without acknowledgement and review.
>
> It also goes for NEW documents putting on site, or you have choosen to
> turn blind eye to mandating things and protecting bad things on site,
> but to forbid changes.
>
> I agree site is not a wiki, like I already said, but it is only obvious
> you are not using your own rules like you describe.
>
> >
> >> Xenol used it's right to change, by putting it, I don't see the
> >> difference here.
> > Adam created new content, you modified existing content.
>
> And that is great to do.
>
> Ok, then On Wiki, I created the content and he is modifyoing existing
> content.
>
> I don't thing people should be forbidden to modify existing content.
>
> >> People tend to even say things without even looking,
> >> and it is obvious that pushing document on the site is avoiding any
> >> procedure and community effort and that is bad behaviour that tend to
> >> spread.
> >> As long it is there site is under occupation from that troll document.
> >>
> >> You can of course do whatever you want, it's always your free choice.
> > Do you consider that the group of active developers steering the project
> misbehave by proposing a form of organisation to help OpenIndiana move
> forward?
>
> Of course they do. Plus they propose that trolling is the norm in this
> community, obviously facilitated by makruger idea of ruling.
>
> I say everyone do what knows best that proposed document is clearly full
> of logical and inhumane intentional mistakes that are to destroy this
> community in the long run.
>
> Just take alook at the actual changes and refer on them and be on topic.
>
> > The need of a Code of Conduct was discussed within the group, ideas
> emerged and are thus proposed to the community.
> > Sounds pretty reasonable to me. :)
>
> No it is never discussed before in open, before making this topic,
> anywhere, not even on IRC.
>
> If it is done in secrecy, that is grouse misbehaviour.
> As I see there is no comunity but xenol pushing it on site and some
> trolling content in it.
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> oi-dev mailing list
> oi-dev at openindiana.org
> http://openindiana.org/mailman/listinfo/oi-dev
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://openindiana.org/pipermail/oi-dev/attachments/20160725/59a77ed7/attachment-0005.html>